The 9 Best Shaving Soaps for Safety Razor: 2018 Reviews & Guide

Updated 6 years ago

Shaving soaps have been around for a long time now. They have evolved through the years, as evidenced by the use of revolutionary ingredients that promise to be gentle on the skin and will help to have a closer shave. They are essential for an old-school shave, especially for men who would like to give their beards a trim. Even for women shaving their legs, these soaps are great.

If you go online and search for shaving soaps, you will most likely be overwhelmed with the long list of choices that will confront you. Nonetheless, this does not mean that you can choose just any product and expect it to deliver superior quality. You need to exercise responsibility and take the time to scrutinize the possibilities to make a decision that won’t bring regrets.

Top picks for a shaving soap

Below are nine of the shaving soaps that you can use with a safety razor. To make it easier for you to decide which one to buy, I will also discuss some of the things that make them remarkable.

Product name Main Ingredients Price
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl Eucalyptus, menthol $
Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap Shea butter, coconut oil, soy extracts $
Col. Conk Bay Rum Shave Soap Avocado oil, Vitamin E $
The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap Coconut oil, stearic acid, vegetable glycerin $$
Sir Hare Shaving Soap Sunflower oil, grapeseed oil, coconut oil, glycerin $$
WSP Rustic Shaving Soap Coconut oil, glycerin, stearic acid $
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap Shea butter, Vitamin E, coconut oil $
Van der Hagen Deluxe Shave Soap Aloe vera, shea butter $$
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap Water, stearic acid, coconut acid $$

Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl

With the use of this rich and creamy soap, shaving with a safety razor is sure to be a lot easier. There is a lesser likelihood that your skin will end up suffering from irritation. Most importantly, you can be assured of a close shave.

One of the main ingredients in this shaving soap is eucalyptus oil, which is known for its toning benefits. It also contains menthol, which is refreshing and revitalizing, making you feel better after every shave.

This shaving oil has been around since 1948 and recognized as a top barber’s choice since then, providing it with a reputation that is hard to rival. It is even made better by the fact that it does not contain toxic chemicals.

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap

This American-made soap provides lubrication to make sure that the safety razor will glide smoothly on the skin. Both the gents and ladies will love how the soap will result in closer, comfortable, and cushioned shaving.

One of the key ingredients that you can find in this soap is shea butter, which can effectively replenish and revitalize dull skin. Meanwhile, there are also soy extracts that can make the skin softer to be more comfortable when shaving. Lastly, the coconut oil provides a moisturizing effect on the skin.

The soap comes with a light and minimal scent. This is unlike in the case of other soaps with a strong and chemical-like odor.

Col. Conk Bay Rum Shave Soap

The World’s Famous Glycerin Soap – this is the company’s tagline, which should already make you confident in the quality of the product. It has a weight of only 2.25 ounces, which makes it lightweight and portable for people who are on the go.

Another thing that makes this exceptional is that it has been milled three times. After milling it for three times, it is stamped and molded. The process of the production ensures the density of the soap, making it last longer.

The company has been in the business for more than 150 years. For a business to last that long, it is pretty much obvious that they are doing something right.

The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap

Packaged in a gold tin, this is a luxury soap that does not fail to meet expectations. One of its main ingredients is coconut oil, which is known for having natural moisturizing properties, making the skin softer as you use a safety razor.

This specific product has a Smolder scent, which is warm and light. It is never overpowering. The scent will remind you of the combination of coriander, orange peel, and anise. Because of its scent, it is no longer surprising that many people refer to it as bottled masculinity.

Sir Hare Shaving Soap

This soap is handcrafted with the use of the best ingredients that are available. It is in a beautiful container with a waterproof label. The inventive logo is also a plus, which is sure to catch your attention.

The combination of the natural ingredients in this soap allows it to provide a moisturizing effect and layer of protection so that the skin will not be easily prone to irritation when you are shaving. It also prevents dryness and the appearance of razor bumps.

Lastly, the manufacturer also offers a no-hassle guarantee, which can provide you with peace of mind.

WSP Rustic Shaving Soap

If you are looking for a natural vegan soap, without a doubt, this should be on the top of the list. It has a concentrated formula and made from naturally-selected ingredients. There are no synthetic dyes and preservatives that are used in the soap. It also does not contain water filler.

Your money will not be put to waste should you decide to choose this shaving soap. This is basically because the manufacturer offers a free refund if you are not 100% satisfied with the use of this shaving soap.

Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap

This soap will create a rich lather for a smoother shave. If you have sensitive skin that is prone to irritation, this soap can offer the perfect solution. Plus, it has a mild scent that won’t be too much for anyone to bear.

Looking at the list of the ingredients that are used, you will also be happy to know that it does not contain parabens, preservatives, dyes, and synthetic fragrances, among others. It will hydrate and moisturize in the absence of delivering adverse effects.

Van der Hagen Deluxe Shave Soap

One of the most important things that should be pointed out about this soap is that it contains 40% moisturizers. They will work together to make the surface of the skin as smooth as possible so that the safety razor will glide effortlessly, leaving no bumps and irritation.

This is specially formulated for a heavy beard. Before shaving, applying the soap will make the beard gentler and hence, you will find it a lot easier to shave. For women with thick hair, the soap can also do wonders.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap

This sandalwood herbal soap is another great choice that should be part of your list. Given the ingredients that are used, it will lather smoothly on the face and will make the skin softer and smoother for a better shaving experience.

Another good thing about this soap is that it is packaged in a wooden bowl, which makes it good-looking. The wooden bowl can also be refilled.

This soap makes use of high-quality essential oils that do not have any chemical-like odor. It has a subtle, woodsy, and manly smell.

Types of shaving soaps

As you try to narrow down the possibilities, it is important that you are aware of the different types of shaving soaps that are available on the market, which include the following:

  • Triple-Milled: This is the most common of the three types of shaving soaps. Under this process, the soap is milled three times before it is stamped and packaged. This results in higher density, making the soap last longer.
  • Croap: If you are looking for something that is softer than a traditional soap, this is your best bet. It has a creamy texture, which makes it easy to apply. It can add more moisture to the skin.
  • Semi-Hard: As the name suggests, this is the middle line between the two types that are mentioned above. This will allow you to enjoy the best of both worlds, although most people will probably just choose between soft and hard, nothing in between.

Aside from their form, shaving soaps can also be classified on the basis of the ingredients that are used. In this case, the following are the choices that you will have:

  • Tallow-Based: This is what you can find in most of the old-school shaving soaps. This is a soap that makes use of animal fat as the main ingredient.
  • Glycerin-Based: This is believed to be a gentle ingredient, which makes it the best for people who have sensitive skin.
  • Oil-Based: Most of the oil-based soaps use natural ingredients with moisturizing benefits, such as olive, coconut, and palm oil.